piper_chuck
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- May 25, 2005
- Messages
- 2,436
I posted this in the other thread, but not sure if everyone is reading both, so here it is again:
I did a bit of a comparison between the NAMBA nats and IMPBA internats for 2007. Here are some numbers.
Stat: NAMBA:IMPBA
Tot days: 10:9 (includes open water days)
Race days: 8:7
Boats/day: 72:44
Boats: 576:310 (numbers came from totaling the published entry lists)
Classes: 35:21 (includes specialty classes)
boats/class: 16.5:14.8
Following are some observations from looking at the races and formats. I don't know if the differences are good or bad, I'm posting these as discussion points to see if there are any lessons we (IMPBA) can learn.
I did a bit of a comparison between the NAMBA nats and IMPBA internats for 2007. Here are some numbers.
Stat: NAMBA:IMPBA
Tot days: 10:9 (includes open water days)
Race days: 8:7
Boats/day: 72:44
Boats: 576:310 (numbers came from totaling the published entry lists)
Classes: 35:21 (includes specialty classes)
boats/class: 16.5:14.8
Following are some observations from looking at the races and formats. I don't know if the differences are good or bad, I'm posting these as discussion points to see if there are any lessons we (IMPBA) can learn.
- It appears that NAMBA starts and completes a class in one day. In order to do this, they schedule a smaller number of classes for the day. IMPBA schedules more classes per day and spreads their heat racing over 2 days. If someone wanted to compete in just one class in the NAMBA nats, they could show up early that day for open water, compete, and then go home. An IMPBA competitor hoping to go home with a trophy needs to attend a minimum of 3 days (2 race days and one trials day, if the trials doesn't run into a second day). Also, if the person isn't local, this 3 day minimum only works for the classes which precede the trials. If they want to run the other classes, the would need to attend 5 days or more.
- NAMBA appears to mix up the schedule so they only run one size of a boat type (mono, tunnel, hydro, sport hydro, etc) per day. This allows someone who specializes in a specific boat type to focus on just one boat per day. IMPBA has a larger number of classes competing on the same day(s), so there are usually a couple different sizes of the same type that will be competing on the same days. This means an IMPBA racer running multiple sizes of a type of boat may need to prep more than one boat for a given day. In addition, someone competing in IMPBA will need to prep their boat(s) again for the time trials day(s).
- The NAMBA schedule shows open water every morning before racing began. The IMPBA schedule has conditional (time permitting) open water at the end of the day for boats running the following day. As mentioned earlier, this means at the NAMBA nats a person only has to prep a boat for one day. At the IMPBA nats, a racer might not even get any open water, other than the two days before racing begins, before they race.
- NAMBA handled significantly more boats per day than IMPBA. Obviously, not running the timed trials was part of the reason for this. Were there other differences, perhaps less heats?
- Does the location have an impact on the attendance? Since many have said local attendance is a big part of the attendance at the national events, perhaps when the race is hosted in an active geography it will receive larger attendance.
- Do the NAMBA drivers who win their class feel somehow diminished because they didn't have a timed straight and oval as part of their win?