Firefighters red-faced after new fireboat fizzles
When its moment of fame finally came, $1.7 million vessel failed to
deliver
By HECTOR CASTRO
P-I REPORTER
The dramatic images on TV during Seafair captured it all -- a ball of
flame that once was a hydroplane, and a boat pouring a stream of white
foam to douse it.
But the boat fighting the fire that
engulfed the hydroplane during the
Chevrolet Cup races on Aug. 6
wasn't the Seattle Fire Department's
shiny new $1.7 million fireboat,
Engine 1.
With a rivalry that already exists
between the Seattle Police
Department's Harbor Patrol and the
Fire Department boat crews, the
incident was bound to be noticed.ith a rivalry that already exists
between the Seattle Police
Department's Harbor Patrol and the
Fire Department boat crews, the
incident was bound to be noticed.
A blue-and-white police responder actually put out the hydro fire when
Engine 1's hoses produced nothing but a trickle.
"It was probably the worst day of my career," said fire Engineer Dick
Chester, who was aboard Engine 1 on the lake that day.
Publicly, Harbor Patrol officers are being diplomatic.
"Every one of us has the potential for equipment failure or malfunction,"
police Sgt. Kevin Haistings said.
Privately, firefighters are embarrassed.
Engine 1 was inaugurated last month with Mayor Greg Nickels touting
it as a state-of-the-art fireboat capable of pumping 6,000 gallons a
minute, traveling more than 25 mph and, at 50 feet, able to maneuver
more easily among Seattle's multiple piers and marinas.
With the equipment it carries, the vessel is supposed to be
able to protect its crew
fighting fires or handling
incidents involving
chemical, biological or
radiological materials.
The boat was built by
MetalCraft Marine, a
leading name in search
and rescue craft. And a
senior engineer visited
frequently. He was also
there when Engine 1
went through sea trials in May.
On July 15, Nickels took part in Engine 1's delivery to Station 5 on
Elliott Bay, where it will be berthed.
When Seafair rolled around, Engine 1 was there.
"It was ready to go," Chester said.
The gleaming new boat, with a pilot room still boasting that new-car
smell, was just one of several vessels on Lake Washington that
weekend, the others coming from Harbor Patrol, the U.S. Coast Guard,
the King County Sheriff's Office and other agencies.
When the hydroplane caught fire, forcing its driver to leap into the
water, Patrol 1, a police boat with a hose, began working on the fire.
Patrol 1 has no water canon. So, when Engine 1 arrived at the scene, it
was to be its debut.
"As soon as Engine 1 was ready to initiate an attack, we shut our
pumps down and maneuvered out of the way," Haistings said.
The monitors on Engine 1 can fire a stream of water or foam mixed
with water at 2,000 gallons a minute.
But when the new vessel steamed over to the burning hydroplane and
the switch was thrown to start pouring water on the blaze, Engine 1
failed to perform. The stream that came out was little more than a
trickle.
The crew was horrified.
"I probably took it the hardest, 'cause I didn't expect it," Chester said.
With the hydro still in flames, the police boat Patrol 4 took over the
attack, blasting the burning vessel with foam from one of its monitors.
Meanwhile, the crew aboard Engine 1 was frantically trying to figure
out what went wrong.
The problem turned out to be air. The monitors on the fireboat, which
look like large water guns, suck water in through pumps in the engine
room. The water for those pumps is kept in two chambers called "sea
chests," basically square holes in the hull covered with an airtight metal
box.
Churn from the boat's powerful jet motors aerated the water going into
the sea chests, so when the pumps wanted to suck in water, all they got
was air, Chester said.
He ended up having to crawl into the engine compartment and manually
pop the lids of the sea chests to release all the air that had become
trapped in there.
"Then, boom, we had it," he said.
But by then, Patrol 4 and the Chief Seattle had succeeded in putting out
the fire.
Engine 1 has been out of commission since the fire.
Friday, Chester was busy installing valves in the sea chests that will
allow air trapped in them to escape.
The crews tested the boat over the weekend and made sure the
modification worked.
Chester is confident the alterations will continue to work, but it will be
some time before the crews forget the Seafair debacle.
"We were all kind of down 'cause of what happened," he said.
Still, the engineer has not lost faith in the department's newest vessel.
"It's a great boat, once we get the bugs worked out," he said.