Mike what KV motor are you running? Generally sport 21 props tend to work well. X440/3, GR38x63, ABC 1914/1915. If you have a lower kv motor, go up in size from the ones recommended. I would stick with low lift props.
Try any of those props mentioned as a good starting point. You can add pitch or diameter based on motor temps and attitude of the boat. The X440/3 was the smoothest, most consistent prop for my P-Ltd Phil Thomas sport boat. Not the fastest, but handled nicely.